Tax Deductibility of Home Equity Debt
The tax treatment of home equity loan and HELOC interest changed significantly with the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act of 2017. Previously, interest on up to 100,000 dollars of home equity debt was tax-deductible regardless of how you used the money. Current law allows deducting interest only if you use the borrowed funds to buy, build, or substantially improve the home securing the loan, and only on total mortgage debt up to 750,000 dollars for married couples filing jointly or 375,000 dollars for single filers.
This means if you borrow 40,000 dollars through a home equity loan to remodel your kitchen, the interest is potentially tax-deductible if you itemize deductions and haven't exceeded the 750,000 dollar limit. However, if you use the same 40,000 dollars to pay off credit cards, fund a vacation, or buy a car, the interest is not deductible. The loan purpose, not the loan type, determines deductibility.
For homeowners in the 24 percent tax bracket, deductible interest effectively costs less than the stated rate. A 7 percent deductible loan has an after-tax cost of 5.32 percent (7% × (1 - 0.24)). However, with the increased standard deduction, many taxpayers no longer itemize and receive no benefit from mortgage interest deductibility. Consult a tax professional to determine whether you'll benefit from deducting home equity loan interest before factoring tax savings into your decision.
Appropriate Uses for Home Equity
Home equity borrowing makes most sense for expenses that increase your net worth or have long-term value. Home renovations that increase your property's value are ideal uses, especially if the improvements provide returns approaching or exceeding the cost. Borrowing 60,000 dollars at 6.5 percent to remodel a kitchen that adds 70,000 dollars in home value while you enjoy the upgraded space for years creates positive financial value.
Debt consolidation represents another strategic use when you replace high-interest debt with lower-rate home equity borrowing. Consolidating 35,000 dollars in credit card debt at 18 percent into a home equity loan at 7 percent saves approximately 6,000 dollars in annual interest, freeing up cash flow for savings and investment. However, this strategy requires discipline—paying off credit cards with home equity, then accumulating new credit card debt, leaves you worse off than before with your home at risk.
Education expenses, emergency medical bills, or starting a business can justify home equity borrowing in specific situations. The key question is whether the expense provides value exceeding the cost of borrowing and whether alternative funding sources exist. Avoid using home equity for depreciating assets like cars, vacations, or everyday living expenses. Your home shouldn't subsidize lifestyle spending you can't otherwise afford.
Risks and Considerations
The most significant risk of home equity borrowing is putting your home at stake. Unlike credit cards or personal loans where defaulting damages your credit and may result in lawsuits, failing to repay home equity debt can lead to foreclosure and loss of your home. This risk deserves serious consideration, especially if your income or employment situation is unstable.
Variable interest rates on HELOCs expose you to payment increases when rates rise. A HELOC at 5.5 percent with a 50,000 dollar balance requires approximately 229 dollars in interest-only payments monthly. If rates increase to 8.5 percent over several years, that payment jumps to 354 dollars—a 125 dollar monthly increase. When the repayment period begins, payments could exceed 600 dollars depending on the remaining balance and term. Ensure you can handle potential payment increases before choosing a variable-rate product.
Closing costs on home equity products range from minimal fees to 2 to 5 percent of the amount borrowed, depending on the lender and loan size. Application fees, appraisal costs, title searches, and recording fees add up quickly. Some lenders advertise no-closing-cost products but build costs into a higher interest rate or require you to maintain the loan for a minimum period to avoid repayment of waived fees. Calculate whether you'll keep the loan long enough to justify any upfront costs.
Strategic Borrowing Approaches
If you need funds but uncertainty exists about the amount or timing, a HELOC provides flexibility without paying interest on unused credit. Establish the line during favorable market conditions when rates are low and you easily qualify, then tap it only as needed. Many HELOCs charge no annual fees or maintenance costs for unused credit lines, providing peace of mind at no cost.
Consider the payment structure carefully when choosing between home equity loans and HELOCs. If you value payment predictability and plan to borrow a known amount for a specific purpose, fixed-rate home equity loans provide stability. If you have ongoing expenses over time, need emergency access to capital, or believe interest rates will decrease, HELOCs offer advantages despite variable rates.
Shop multiple lenders for the best terms, as rates and fees vary considerably. Credit unions often provide competitive rates, while online lenders may offer streamlined applications and quick funding. Negotiate fees when possible—many costs are negotiable, especially for borrowers with excellent credit and substantial equity. Some lenders waive appraisal requirements if you recently refinanced or purchased the home, saving several hundred dollars.