Tax Treatment of Severance Pay
Severance is ordinary income — taxed at your marginal federal and state rates, subject to Social Security (up to the wage base, if not already exceeded) and Medicare taxes. Your employer withholds taxes from severance at either the supplemental wage withholding rate (22% for amounts up to $1 million in 2024) or at your regular withholding rate. The supplemental rate often causes underwithholding for people in higher brackets: if your marginal rate is 32%, withholding at 22% means you'll owe the additional 10% when you file your taxes.
Kate, 42, in Boston, Massachusetts received $38,000 in severance after 9 years at her company. Her employer withheld 22% federal ($8,360) plus 5% Massachusetts state tax ($1,900) = $10,260 total withholding. Her marginal federal rate is 24% and Massachusetts taxes at 5%. Actual federal tax on $38,000: 24% = $9,120. She owes $760 more than withheld in federal tax — she should either adjust estimated tax payments or be prepared for a tax bill when she files. For people in the 32% or 35% brackets receiving large severance packages, the underwitholding gap can be $5,000 to $15,000.
What Affects Severance Amount: Negotiable Factors
Even at companies with standard formulas, there are often negotiable elements around termination that affect total departing compensation. COBRA continuation: COBRA (continuation of employer health benefits) typically costs $600 to $2,200 per month for self-only coverage and $1,500 to $4,500 for family coverage — dramatically more than the employee-share contribution. Negotiating 2 to 6 months of COBRA premium coverage as part of the departure package is common and can add significant value.
Unvested stock or equity: depending on company policy and departure circumstances, negotiating accelerated vesting of unvested stock options or RSUs is sometimes possible, particularly for senior employees or in situations where the employer is downsizing (suggesting the termination is company-driven rather than performance-based). At a startup where your unvested options represent significant value, this negotiation can dwarf the cash severance in total value.
Commission on deals in progress: sales professionals terminated mid-quarter often have deals that will close after their departure. Many severance agreements attempt to exclude commission on these deals. Negotiating commission owed on sales you originated or materially advanced, even if they close after termination, is legitimate and often worth fighting for specifically.
When to Consider an Employment Attorney
If your termination involved potential discrimination, retaliation for protected activity (reporting illegal conduct, filing workers' compensation claims, taking FMLA leave), or violation of an employment contract, your legal claim may be worth more than the offered severance — meaning signing the release could cost you significant money. An initial consultation with an employment attorney typically costs $150 to $350 and can clarify whether your situation has merit that changes the negotiation calculus. Many employment attorneys work on contingency for discrimination and wrongful termination cases.
Even without a specific legal claim, an employment attorney can review your severance agreement for provisions that are unusually restrictive, illegal in your state, or negotiable — particularly non-compete language, commission treatment, and equity provisions. For executives and senior professionals receiving severance packages exceeding $50,000, professional review of the agreement costs far less than the value it can protect.